Use our new account feature to register for a free CLI account. Your new account will allow you to bookmark and organize articles and research for easy reference later - making it simple to keep track of the research that's important to you!
Register / Sign in
close-panel

Charlotte Lozier Institute

Phone: 202-223-8073
Fax: 571-312-0544

2776 S. Arlington Mill Dr.
#803
Arlington, VA 22206

Get Notifications

Sign up to receive email updates from Charlotte Lozier Institute.

Become A Defender of Life

Your donation helps us continue to provide world-class research in defense of life.

DONATE

Charlotte Lozier Institute

Phone: 202-223-8073
Fax: 571-312-0544

2776 S. Arlington Mill Dr.
#803
Arlington, VA 22206

End of Life

Connecticut State Medical Society’s “Engaged Neutrality” on Physician-Assisted Suicide Concerns Physicians

Update: HB 5898, the assisted suicide bill, failed to receive enough support to be voted out of committee. CT News Junkie reports: “…Its chief proponent threw in the towel Monday, not allowing the bill to come up for vote in front of the Public Health Committee. ‘We just didn’t have the votes,’ Rep. Jonathan Steinberg, D-Westport, co-chair of the committee said. He said it also won’t be an issue next year since the membership of the committee won’t change.”

 

 

The Public Health Committee of the Connecticut General Assembly may soon vote on HB 5898, a bill to legalize physician-assisted suicide. This past February, the Connecticut State Medical Society (CSMS) abandoned its long-held stance of opposition to physician-assisted suicide for a position they term “engaged neutrality.” However, some physicians who treat patients at the end of life, and others, have expressed well-founded concerns about how a policy that is anything short of clear opposition would affect their practice.

 

Last week, hospice physician Dr. Joseph Andrews, Jr. announced his resignation from the Connecticut State Medical Society. Dr. Andrews cited the Hippocratic Oath he took 51 years ago and argued that there is “no effective or practical way to grant a ‘right’” to a small subset of individuals choosing death without calls for this door to open wider as a general right for all.

 

Dr. Andrews predicts that the legalization and normalization of assisted suicide as a medical practice would corrode his doctor-patient relationship:

 

“Once the door is opened here, it will open wider and wider. This explains the extraordinary fear and anxiety among people with progressive, chronic, non-fatal illnesses. They wisely fear the creeping growth of assisted dying and are acutely aware that politicians and their physician enablers will start ‘quality of life’ discussions which may result in curtailed access to ‘futile care.’”

 

He states further:

 

“Disabled people can judge their own quality of life, and they remind us that in a good society the weak are safe and the strong are just. Disabilities concentrate the mind wonderfully: behind the ‘quality of life’ smokescreen they see shadows of the Nuremberg laws and the ‘cleansing’ from society of ‘life unworthy of life.’”

 

Speaking from experience, other physicians in states that have passed assisted suicide laws have confirmed that some of their seriously ill patients have shown greater distrust and even fear of doctors.

 

Lastly, Dr. Andrews points to Canada, where the law tramples physicians’ consciences, requiring objecting doctors to obtain the services of a colleague who will assist a patient’s suicide, or else face sanctions.

 

It is tragic and alarming, but hardly unpredictable, that as Connecticut once again considers legalizing assisted suicide and its state medical society sinks into neutrality, physicians like Dr. Andrews believe the only ethical and principled way forward is to drop out of their organizations – potentially even the medical profession – rather than comply.

 

Latest Posts

February 2, 2023 Effects of Pressure to Abort on Women’s Emotional Responses and Mental Health February 1, 2023 Abortion Reporting: Hawaii (2020) January 30, 2023 Abortion Reporting: Pennsylvania (2021)

You Might Also Be Interested In

Lethal Non-Compliance with Washington’s “Death with Dignity Act”

Lethal Non-Compliance with Washington’s “Death with Dignity Act”

December 20, 2022
Studies Confirm: Legalizing Physician-Assisted Suicide Does Not Save Lives

Studies Confirm: Legalizing Physician-Assisted Suicide Does Not Save Lives

charlotte-lozier-institute Charlotte Lozier Institute
December 16, 2022

Map: Assisted Suicide in the States

charlotte-lozier-institute Charlotte Lozier Institute
April 29, 2021

Become A Defender of Life

Your donation helps us continue to provide world-
class research in defense of life.

BECOME A PARTNER
cta-image